Tiesday, 10th November 2009
Howzit
"The trial on terrorism charges of Roy Bennett, a close aide of the Zimbabwean Prime Minister, Morgan Tsvangirai, began yesterday amid claims that the evidence against him was based solely on a confession of an associate made under torture.
Mr Bennett, 52, treasurer of Mr Tsvangirai’s Movement for Democratic Change and Deputy Agriculture Minister-designate, was arrested in February, hours before he was due to be sworn in, on charges of possession of weapons to commit acts of banditry, insurgency and terror which carry the death penalty.
It emerged in the Harare High Court that the evidence against Mr Bennett was based solely on a "confession" that mentioned him in an alleged plot to assassinate Mr Mugabe in 2006.
Peter Hitschmann, 52, an officially registered arms dealer, who is also a white Zimbabwean, wrote the statement after being tortured, Beatrice Mtetwa, a lawyer, said as the trial opened.
Mr Hitschmann has said previously that military intelligence interrogators burnt him on the buttocks with lighted cigarettes until he fainted from the pain. He went on trial in 2007 for treason and possession of weapons for an alleged plot to kill Mr Mugabe.
"It is unsworn and it is not even signed," Ms Mtetwa said of the confession. "This evidence does not exist." She asked the judge Chinembiri Bhunu, to censure Johannes Tomana, the Attorney-General, for citing demonstrable falsehoods as evidence."
With the loyalty of the law courts sewn up, I do not expect a judge to throw the case out, but I am hopeful that the judge will recognise the manufactured State case, and will rule in favour of Bennett when the case has been heard.
"She said that hen Mr Hitschmann found out he was to be subpoenaed to give evidence against Mr Bennett he approached a senior human rights lawyer to appeal to Mr Tomana that he had no evidence he could give against Mr Bennett.
Within hours of having written to Mr Tomana the lawyer was arrested by police at his home for "attempting to defeat the course of justice", and spent the night in a squalid police cell.
Mr Tsvangirai called on Mr Mugabe to stop the malicious prosecution. Another of Mr Tsvangirai’s constant demands over the past nine months since the inauguration of the coalition Government has been that Mr Mugabe swear in Mr Bennett as deputy minister, to no avail.
During the proceedings police brought into the court room boxes and sacks of what appeared to be ammunition and fuses, and at least one rifle - the munitions Mr Bennett was alleged to have been stockpiling."
It really is amazing that Mugabe's own Attorney-General - one of the people who's unilateral appointment has been a sticking point in the composition of the unity government - should take it upon himself to present the State case, and then attempt to parade his 'evidence' in such a brash manner.
"The high profile trial of MDC treasurer general and deputy minister designate, Roy Bennett, finally opened in the High Court in
Bennett stands accused of possessing dangerous weapons in a bid to dethrone President Robert Mugabe. The charges carry a death sentence or life imprisonment.
During Monday’s trial, both the state, led by Attorney General Johannes Tomana and the defence counsel, led by Beatrice Mtetwa, filed applications questioning each other’s outlines.
The defence wants the state to strike off certain statements attributed to the state’s principal witness Peter Michael Hitshmann in Bennett’s indictment papers.
The defence is adamant evidence contained in Bennett’s indictment papers and attributed to statements by Hitshmann, a firearms dealer and alleged accomplice of Bennett, should be struck off the indictment papers as the latter has disowned it.
As in many legal dramas on television, in the event that Hitschmann does make it to the stand and then refuses to confirm his statements, then the State will have no choice but to declare Hitschmann a 'hostile witness'.
In my mind, it isn't whether the court agrees with the State witness, it is the fact that the 'star' State witness is probably giving evidence under duress...
"In an affidavit deposited with a
He said he signed statements based on false confessions induced by torture and abuse.
"As a result of the torture referred to above and involuntarily I made a number of extracural statements, which were all false and cannot be admissible in court," Hitshmann said.
"In these statements, I inter alia admitted to the conspiracy with which I was being charged and suggested that Mr Roy Bennett was also involved in the conspiracy.
"This was pure fiction and bore no relationship at all to any reality."
This case has been elaborately concocted, and it will be very interesting to see what the trial judge has to say on the matter. It is a case which hasn't just got the Zimbabwean people's interest, but has shown itself worldwide as a litmus stick test for justice in Zimbabwe.
"...Tomana is adamant the defence should be compelled to strike off its own outline and resubmit one which would be responding to Hitshmann’s claims that Bennett was an accomplice.
This was after the defence had instead submitted its outline questioning the necessity of responding to the state papers when Hitshmann subsequently placed an affidavit denying the same statements which the state based as its outline.
During the trial, Mtetwa strongly protested Tomana’s decision to proceed with the matter based on evidence which had been disowned by the state’s key witness.
"I believe that when you have an affidavit statement from a witness saying, 'There is no such evidence I can give,' an Attorney General should look into that issue seriously," Mtetwa told the court.
"The Attorney General has a record of proceedings where an accused person gave evidence on oath and was believed by the court.
"It is on that basis that we are saying he is not acting impartially. He is not discharging his duties as expected of a lawyer.
"Clearly the state cannot apply to have the accused person gagged because it does not like what is in the defence outline."
"
Why should Mugabe allow Biti to be sworn in, whilst Bennett was refused the same privelege?
Mugabe can't have it both ways - but, as with most things Zimbabwean and Mugabe, he does and gets away with it!
Since when does such inconsistency become acceptable - not only in Zimbabwe, but in the whole world?
And while we are at it. how come the loser of an election is allowed to continue ruling, together with his beaten party?
I love it! If it were in a book, it would have been dismissed as fanciful garbage...
"The military top brass, working in cahoots with Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe Governor Gideon Gono, have attempted to frame Finance Minister Tendai Biti for treason, authoritative MDC, government and intelligence sources have confirmed.
The plot is widely seen as either a stalling tactic or retaliation for Biti’s probe into US$45m missing from the central bank.
Biti's investigation uncovered scandal at the RBZ, including the revelation that, between December and August, Gono siphoned off US$45m from the RBZ. The money had been a statutory reserve meant to provide financial cover to banks in trouble.
Gono claims the money was used to bankroll the troubled airline, Air
Biti presented a full report on this plunder to Mugabe last week. Another report has been sent to Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara."
Mugabe must live in fear that most, if not all, of his illegal moves and deals are in danger of not only being proved, but given their seriousness, he should face prosecution and a lengthy jail sentence - together with quite a number of his senior loyalists and security chiefs.
Mugabe is no stranger to prison, having been held by the Rhodesians for quite a number of years. What a pity that he chose to plunder Zimbabwe and her resources instead of doing something akin to Nelson Mandela in 1994.
"An investigation by an International Monetary Fund (IMF) technical team also corroborated Biti’s findings, and said Gono had stolen US$45.5m from the RBZ.
"The RBZ has used foreign reserve assets to fund its operating expenses, withdrawals of foreign currency amounts and debt service, as well as payments on behalf of the government," the damning IMF report stated. “The total value of fund outflows is reported to have been US$45.5 million between end-December 2008 and end-August. The RBZ also accumulated US$40.3 million in arrears on operating expenses during the first nine months of 2009.”
Gono came out guns blazing, and co-ordinated a response to what he saw as Biti’s continued effort to embarrass him.
In a desperate bid to forestall the exposure, there was a contrived plot, hatched by the Joint Operations Command, which continues to meet illegally, and Gono, to frame Biti, our source said.
The Zimbabwean on Tuesday heard that the plot against Biti involved 20 AK-47 rifles, reportedly missing from the highly-secured
Authoritative sources said this week the operation was botched after armed police hurriedly raided Biti’s Chisipite home two weeks ago, before the weapons had been planted. The search uncovered nothing.
There was now a manhunt for the 12 soldiers who have disappeared with the weapons without planting them at Biti's home."
Gono is considered by Mugabe not to be a thief, although it is a known fact that he removed foreign currency from accounts he;d at the RBZ - and that money has yet to be replaced.
What I am quite staggered by, is although the IMF has proved beyond a reasonable doubt that much of Gono's activities were illegal and done with the knowledge of Robert Mugabe, there is still no call for Gono or Mugabe to face criminal charges.
"The long history of ZANU PF planting weapons and pressing charges of treason are age-old, tired tactics of the ZANU PF dictatorship, but they must know that this is a serious attack on our movement and we will not back down," Biti said then.
Now MDC Transport Manager, Pascal Gwezere, has been abducted and jailed in connection with the missing weapons.
Sources, however, say it is close to impossible to steal anything from the high-security One Engineers Support Regiment Armoury, from where the 20 Ak-47 rifles are said to have been stolen."
Mugabe has a habit of concentrating on one part of his decpetion, and then, having dragged the attention of observers in one direction, he enacted some atrocity elsewhere.
Watch this space...
"A tortured MDC activist died recently from the injuries that he sustained when he was tortured by state security agents and other supporters of President Robert Mugabe’s ZANU PF party after the elections last year.
Gift Nhidza (32), a former security officer in the MDC, died two weeks ago in Odzi - a politically-volatile area in the country’s eastern
Nhidza, popularly known as "Children", lived as a political refugee in
Nhidza, also a former soldier, sustained horrific injuries when he was brutalised by ZANU PF torture gangs in 2008, allegedly at the instigation of then minister of transport, Christopher Mushohwe."
Mugabe and his faithful followers will not respond to this report and will remain silent on the allegations. To them Nhidza is just another MDC voter that they no longer have to worry about.
A callous and damaging attitude.
'debvhu





















Union Jack (1963 - 64, 1998 - ??)































